Remembering Bob

Update 2010.01.03: Corrected all links to the old Gowanus Lounge domain to the new memorial domain.


Thursday night I attended the Flatbush Development Corporation’s (FDC) 34th Anniversary Benefit Dinner. In my remarks, as one of the honorees, I spoke of the connections and communities that had brought me there that night: my partner, my neighborhood, Flatbush at large, and the Brooklyn blogosphere. I also told the 200+ people assembled there that Brooklyn bloggers had lost one of our own last week: Robert Guskind, founder of Gowanus Lounge, a friend and supporter of this blog and of Flatbush preservation efforts.

I only met Bob in person a few times. We launched our blogs within one month of each other in 2006: Gowanus Lounge in April, Flatbush Gardener in May. Gowanus Lounge quickly became Bob’s bully pulpit from which he could speak, as friend and neighbor Brenda Becker phrased so well, as “Fool-Killer and Weasel-Slayer.” I don’t remember when I first discovered Gowanus Lounge, but the first links from there to this blog appeared in November of that year.

Bob liked – or at least thought least unflattering! – this picture I took of him at the 2nd Annual Brooklyn Blogfest in 2007.
Robert Guskind, Gowanus Lounge

When the Second Brooklyn Blogfest came around in May 2007, we knew each other well from our online endeavors. We didn’t get to meet at that time; it was too crowded, and too hectic. Bob, a speaker at the event, was an A-List blogger of the Brooklyn blogosphere, swarmed with fans, colleagues, and reporters.

Dave Kenny, another friend and blogging colleague, and I co-founded the Brooklyn Blogade as a way to continue the energy and relationship-building from the Blogfest, and expand into neighborhoods that were “underserved” by the Brooklyn blogosphere. Dave credits a discussion with Bob after the 2007 Blogfest as inspiring him to start the Blogades. With Anne Pope of Sustainable Flatbush, I co-hosted the first Blogade here in Flatbush in June 2007, and that’s where Bob and I finally got to meet in person. The New York Times covered that first Blogade; a photograph from the event opens their article in this weekend’s The City section on the future of Gowanus Lounge, the first time any of those photos have appeared.

I met Bob again on only two occasions after that. Most of our communication was online, through email, tips, and mutual links. I don’t know how many scores of times Bob linked to this blog. I was especially touched by his last link at the end of January, in which he referred to me as “a friend and fellow blogger.” As I write this, I still can’t believe he’s gone. We were the same age, and I wish there had been more opportunities and time for us to strengthen that friendship.

As many others have reported in their remembrances of him, Bob was generous in linking. He brought attention to many neighborhood issues that, I believe, without his support would have been overlooked not only by the general press, but other bloggers as well. He nurtured community in the Brooklyn blogosphere. When I reached out to him by email during lasts fall’s hiatus on Gowanus Lounge, he said that he had received “hundreds of emails and comments.” In response to his death, nearly 80 people have written their own condolences and memorial posts to Bob. There are many hundreds more comments across all those posts. That stands as a testament to the impact he has had, and will continue to have after his death.

He was generous and passionate, sensitive and courageous, humorous and outspoken, gregarious and private. I have learned only since his death that we shared a journey in recovery, different in the details, similar in struggle and spirit. I did not know Bob well enough or long enough to know the circumstances of his life or death. Whatever the circumstances, I have nothing but empathy for the man; they cannot diminish my opinion of him. Real people are complex, their circumstances, usually complicated. It’s cost me a lot to learn that.

This was Bob’s favorite of my photos. I know this, not only because the subject shows Coney Island – among Bob’s greatest passions – in its glory, but because he chose this from the Flickr-Moo mini-cards I handed out at 2007’s Blogfest and the first Brooklyn Blogade. If there is a heaven, may this be part of Bob’s.
Sunset Over Coney Island, April 2006

Meta: Feed Glitch

Update 2009-03-11: Problem resolved. This morning, Feedburner subscriber count is back to the levels of a few days ago,
Update: The problem is largely isolated to Google Reader subscribers. If you use Google Reader to view the feed from this blog, and have been having trouble since March 6, please try re-susbcribing to see if that corrects the problem.
Update: Feedburner stats confirm that my subscribers were cut in half – the number of them, not the individuals – from March 6 to March 7. Still researching the problem.


I just noticed that my count of Feedburner subscribers has suddenly dropped from around 175 to just around 105. I believe this is related to my Feedburner feed getting migrated from the old Feedburner to the new Google/Feedburner.

I just logged into Feedburner and migrated the feed. I’m hoping that fixes the glitch. Please let me know, either via comments and by the email in my profile, if you encounter any lasting problems.

Thanx – Xris

DCP-CB14 briefing on Inclusionary Housing provisions

Brooklyn’s Community Board 14, which covers Flatbush and Midwood, has announced a meeting next week, Thursday, March 19 at 6pm, in the CB14 District Office at 810 East 16th Street:

The New York City Department of City Planning has agreed to brief our Board on the Inclusionary Housing Zoning Text Amendment. This is particularly important because, upon the anticipated adoption of the Flatbush rezoning proposal, these Inclusionary Housing rules will apply to certain portions of our district.
Emergency Executive & Interested Members Meeting, Brooklyn Community Board 14, 2009-03-09

It’s an “emergency” meeting because details for this meeting were not available when they published their March calendar of meetings.

Among the provisions of the recently certified Flatbush Rezoning Proposal are considerations to encourage preservation and development of affordable housing. The zoning mechanism for this is the Inclusionary Housing Program:

By providing a floor area bonus for the construction or preservation of affordable housing, inclusionary zoning harnesses the strength of the city’s housing market to create a mix of units for low- and moderate-income families along with market-rate apartments.

The expanded [in 2005] Inclusionary Housing Program, which can be applied in areas being rezoned to medium- and high-density residential districts, combines a zoning floor area bonus with a variety of housing subsidy programs to create powerful incentives for the development and preservation of affordable housing. Developments taking advantage of the full bonus in the new program must devote at least 20 percent of their residential floor area to housing that will remain permanently affordable to lower-income households.

The Department of City Planning (DCP) is responsible for identifying eligible areas in rezoning plans, such as that for Flatbush. The Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) is responsible for administering housing built according to the program.

[TinyURL]

Related Content

Flatbush Rezoning Proposal certified, enters public review process, 2009-03-02
New Flatbush Rezoning Proposal Gets It Right, 2008-10-07
Flatbush Rezoning Proposal will define the future of Victorian Flatbush, 2008-06-13

Links

Emergency Executive & Interested Members Meeting, CB14
Inclusionary Housing Program, DCP

Sunday in the Garden

Sunday was warm, highs in the 60s (F). The Crocus were open. And the honeybees were swarming over them.

Honeybee on Crocus tommasinanus
Honeybee on Crocus tommasinianus

There are at least five (5) honeybees in this photo. Can you find them all?
Crocus tommasinianus

This is the third year for these little Crocus tommasinianus. They’ve grown into this small grove from just a handful of corms. Here’s how they looked in March 2007:

Crocus tommasinianus and Eranthis hyemalis

The Eranthis in the above photo have not persisted. You can see how the Crocus have thrived.

Related Content

Other posts about the Front Garden

FDC Benefit Dinner Thursday, March 12

This Thursday, March 12, I am among the Neighborhood Association Honorees at the Flatbush Development Corporation‘s (FDC) 34th Anniversary Celebration dinner at Gargiulo’s Restaurant, in Coney Island, Brooklyn [GMAP]:

FDC traditionally honors people who have made outstanding contributions to the Flatbush community. Along with neighborhood association and business honorees, this year, FDC’s 34th Anniversary Award recipient will be Wendy Weller-Jones, long time neighborhood resident, and FDC volunteer. Her dedication and commitment to Flatbush Development Corporation and the community has been tremendous.

Individual tickets are $135; total contribution less $80.00 per ticket is tax deductible. To purchase tickets, call FDC at (718)859-3800.

The benefit and journal proceeds will help offset the financial cutbacks to our funding from city, state and foundation grants. Proceeds from this event will support the FDC programs and initiatives that help to build a strong community. These include commercial revitalization economic development activities; after-school programs for children and teens; recreation, mediation and health programs for at-risk teenagers; housing assistance to landlords, tenants, homeowners and cooperators; and assistance to our area’s immigrant residents.

Honorees

34th Anniversary Award Recipient

Wendy Weller-Jones

Neighborhood Business Honorees

The Farm on Adderley & Sycamore – Gary Jonas & Allison McDowell
Midwood Martial Arts – Alison Morea & Alfred DiGrazia

Neighborhood Association Honorees

Beverley Square West – Chris Kreussling
Ditmas Park – Nama Taub
Ditmas Park West – Dani Sucher
Fiske Terrace – Judy Hoffman
Midwood Park – Barbara Parisi
Newkirk Area Neighborhood – Giselle Nakhind
West Midwood – Carole and Len Grau

Related Content

Other posts on FDC

Links

Flatbush Development Corporation
Gargiulo’s Restaurant

Rally tomorrow for the Culver Community Garden

Meet at 12noon tomorrow at the corner of 9th Avenue and 39th Street [GMAP] to rally in support of creating a new community garden in Sunset Park: the Culver Community Garden. The group is organizing to convert the currently vacant lots on either side of the 9th Avenue station of the D/M subway line into public green spaces.

Related Content

Sunset Park can haz Community Garden?, 2008-11-25

Links

Best View in Brooklyn
Culver Community Garden

Gowanus Lounge back online

Update 2010.01.03: Corrected all links to the old Gowanus Lounge domain to the new memorial domain.


I just discovered that Gowanus Lounge is back online. There is a placeholder post for future announcements:

With great sadness, a few of Bob’s friends, who were given access to his site, will try to update Gowanus Lounge with:

1) An obituary and other links

2) An announcement of a memorial service

Meanwhile, comments and questions are welcomed. They will be moderated. Please give us time.
Gowanus Lounge Update & Bob Guskind Memorial, 2009-03-06

Related Content

Robert Guskind, founder of Gowanus Lounge, 1958-2009, 2009-03-05

Links

Gowanus Lounge Update & Bob Guskind Memorial, 2009-03-06

Robert Guskind, founder of Gowanus Lounge, 1958-2009

Update 2010.01.03: Corrected all links to the old Gowanus Lounge domain to the new memorial domain.


Update 2009.03.20: A memorial is planned for April 4.
Update 2009.03.14: Finally wrote my memorial post.
Update 2009.03.11: The official, authorized, and epic obituary for Bob, written lovingly by his family and friends, was published online today. Please read In Memoriam, Robert Guskind on Gowanus Lounge.
Updates 2009.03.06:

  • It’s been all I can do just to keep up with the flood of online remembrances and other reports in response to Bob’s death. As of mid-day, there are over 60. Reading everyone’s posts brings back my own memories of Bob, which I hope to post over the weekend.
  • Changed the link for the Brooklyn Paper.

I just learned, from Windsor Terrace Alliance and Brownstoner, that Robert “Bob” Guskind, founder of Gowanus Lounge, was found dead in his home yesterday, March 4, 2009.

He was a colleague, and a friend. I’m stunned, and can’t write anything else right now. See Links below for others’ coverage of this terrible loss.

Robert Guskind, speaking at the second Brooklyn Blogfest in May 2007.
Robert Guskind, Gowanus Lounge


Robert Guskind speaking at the first Brooklyn Blogade, at Vox Pop in Flatbush, in June 2007.

Robert Guskind, Gowanus Lounge

Related content

My Flickr photos of Bob

Links

His work and words

His last video, 2009-03-01
Bob’s videos on YouTube
Bob’s Flickr photos
A Walk Around the Blog episode featuring Bob talking about development in Carroll Gardens
Bob on the Brian Lehrer show, WNYC, 2007-09-20
Reporter Roundtable and Brooklyn Review archival footage from Brooklyn Independent Television
Bob wrote 29 stories for Underground Voices Magazine

News reports

Brooklyn Paper, 2009-03-05 (The text of this article has been edited from its original content.)
Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 2009-03-05
New York Magazine (Warning: Intrusive advertising)
New York Post

Personal remembrances

One post per site. I’ve done my best to keep this list up-to-date. If I’ve overlooked your post, please let me know.

Bob and Miss Heather were good friends.
New York Sh*tty

In alphabetical order

  1. 1 Stop Over in Brooklyn
  2. 66 Square Feet
  3. The Albany Project
  4. Art in Brooklyn
  5. Atlantic Yards Report
  6. Bad Advice
  7. Bay Ridge Journal
  8. Bed-Stuy Banana
  9. Bed-Stuy Blog
  10. Best View in Brooklyn
  11. The Bowery Boys: New York City History
  12. BRIC Community Media
  13. Brooklyn 11211
  14. Brooklyn Born
  15. Brooklyn Heights Blog
  16. Brooklyn Junction
  17. Brooklyn Optimist
  18. Brooklyn Paper
  19. Brooklyn Ron
  20. Brooklyn Streets, Carroll Gardens
  21. Brooklynometry
  22. Brownstoner
  23. Bumpershine
  24. California Greening
  25. Carroll Gardens petition (scroll down past the petition itself)
  26. Clinton Hill Blog
  27. Cobble Hill Blog
  28. Crazy Stable
  29. Curbed (Bob worked at Curbed until this past January)
  30. Dalton Rooney (last paragraph)
  31. Deep in the Heart of Brooklyn
  32. Deluxa
  33. Destination Red Hook
  34. Develop Don’t Destroy Brooklyn
  35. Dope on the Slope
  36. Dumbo NYC
  37. Eat It (opening paragraph to a restaurant review)
  38. Englishman in New York
  39. Flatbush Gardener
  40. Flatbush Vegan
  41. Free Williamsburg
  42. Fort Greene-Clinton Hill, The Local, New York Times
  43. Glamorous Life of the Theatre
  44. Gothamist
  45. Green Brooklyn
  46. Gorilla Face
  47. Huffington Post
  48. I Love Franklin Ave.
  49. I’m not saying, I’m just sayin
  50. IMBY
  51. Keep Left NYC
  52. Kinetic Carnival
  53. Liberty on 10th Street
  54. Living the American Green
  55. lornagrl
  56. Lost City
  57. Lost in the Ozone
  58. McBrooklyn
  59. Make No Assumptions …
  60. mrjabba
  61. Nathan Kensinger Photography
  62. Neighborhood Threat
  63. Neighbors Allied for Good Growth (NAG)
  64. No Land Grab
  65. Not Another F*cking Blog
  66. The “Not-So-Rough” Guide
  67. Only the Blog Knows Brooklyn
  68. Pardon Me For Asking
  69. Pistols and Popcorn
  70. Plasticblog
  71. Pretty in the City
  72. Queens Cr*p
  73. Reclaimed Home
  74. Self-Absorbed Boomer
  75. Space at my moving pace
  76. Street Level
  77. Sunset-Park.com
  78. Triada Samaras Art
  79. Vanishing New York
  80. Washington Square Park

[goo.gl]

Making Brooklyn Bloom this Saturday

This Saturday, March 7, from 10am to 4pm, Greenbridge, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden’s Community Horticulture program, hosts its 28th annual Making Brooklyn Bloom. This year’s theme is Growing Up Green: Guiding Youth from Gardening to Green-Collar Jobs.

Making Brooklyn Bloom

Schedule

  • 10–11 a.m.
    • Registration, Coffee, and Exhibits in the Palm House: You must register on the day of the event to secure space in a workshop.
    • Exhibits of Youth Gardening and Greening Groups
  • 11 a.m.–Noon: Morning Workshops
  • Noon–1:30 p.m.
    • Exhibits in the Palm House
    • Lunch at the Terrace Café: Sandwiches, soup, and salads available
    • Networking Lunch: Advocating for School Gardens
    • Movies: Several short films will be shown in the auditorium beginning at 12:15 p.m., including BBG Children’s Garden footage ca. 1930s, a short film on school gardening, and several videos made by green teens.
    • Activities: View exhibits from NY-area greening organizations · Enjoy the exhibit “My Favorite Garden,” in the Steinhardt Conservatory · Enjoy interactive Discovery Carts in the Garden · Visit the Gift and Garden Shop · Seasonal Guided Walking Tour of the Garden (1–2 p.m) · View a Greenest Block in Brooklyn Contest photo exhibition in the Visitors Center
  • 1:30–2:45 p.m.
    • Featured Speaker Maurice Small
      Keynote Address
      Youth | Soil | Food: Imagine…
      Location: Auditorium, Administration Building
    • Announcements
  • 3–4 p.m.: Afternoon Workshops
  • 4 p.m.: Pick Up a Spring Gift Bag as You Leave!

Workshop Topics

Some of these will be held at 11 a.m. and some at 3 p.m.; the schedule will be announced at registration. You will have a chance to choose only two workshops, one from each time block, space permitting. We recommend that you arrive early to get your first choices.

Kitchen Botany
Barbara Kurland, BBG School Programs manager

Worm Composting Indoors
Luke Halligan, BBG Brooklyn Compost Project

Cooking Up a Healthy Future
EATWISE: Cookshop for Teens, Food Bank for NYC

Interactive Games for Environmental Learning
BBG Garden Apprentice Program

Cultivating Street Tree Stewards
Natalie Wesson and Matt Genrich, GreenApple Corps/NYC Parks & Recreation

Emerging Green-Collar Jobs Panel
Kate Zidar, North Brooklyn Compost Project; Omar Freilla, Green Worker Cooperative; Ian Marvy, Added Value; Annette Williams, Sustainable South Bronx; Brian Aucoin, MillionTrees NYC Training Program

A Brooklyn Girl’s Food Voice: Three Generations of Growing Food
Annie Hauck-Lawson, co-editor of Gastropolis: Food & New York City

A Year in the Garden
Lenny Librizzi, David Saphire, Council on the Environment of NYC; Learn It Eat It Grow It program participants

Growing a Kid’s Kitchen Garden
Caleb Leech, BBG Herb Garden Curator

Building Youth / Adult Alliances
Sarita Daftary and East New York Farms! youth leaders

Starting a Children’s Garden Program
Sara Epstein and Sara Scott, BBG Project Green Reach

Propagation Tips for the Frugal Gardener
Solita Stephens, Just Food/Olympus Garden Club

Rain Gardens for Beginners
Youth Ministries for Peace and Justice youth organizers

All the Dirt on Cultivating Healthy Soil
Monika Hannemann, BBG Discovery Garden program coordinator and Education Greenhouse manager

Drip Irrigation for Community Gardens
Irene Shen, BASE Partnership Director; Kiana Aiken, Tiyi Brewster, Chela Knight, BASE students

Recognizing Pattern in the Landscape and the Classroom
Claudia Joseph, Permaculture Exchange/Garden of Union

Related Content

Making Brookyln Bloom, March 2008 (Flickr photo set)
This Saturday: Green it! Grow it! Eat it! at BBG, 2008-03-04

Links

Making Brooklyn Bloom – Growing Up Green: Guiding Youth from Gardening to Green-Collar Jobs

Flatbush Rezoning Proposal certified, enters public review process

Update 2009-07-29: Flatbush Rezoning Proposal approved by City Council
Update 2009-05-15: The City Planning Commission (CPC) hearing is scheduled for Wednesday, June 3 at their offices at 22 Reade Street in downtown Manhattan. Sign in at 10am to testify.
Update 2009-03-16: Flatbush Rezoning Proposal CB14 Public Hearing April 2
Update 2009-03-10: DCP-CB14 briefing on Inclusionary Housing provisions March 19


Earlier today the City Planning Commission certified the Flatbush Rezoning Proposal. It now enters the public review process that is ULURP: the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure. The proposal covers a huge area: 180 blocks, nearly the entire northern half of Community Board 14.

The proposal, developed over a three year period in close consultation with Community Board 14, community members, local elected officials and neighborhood civic associations, would protect the diversity of scale and character of the area’s Victorian homes, row houses and apartment buildings by updating zoning to reflect the existing built character. The comprehensive community-based proposal furthers the Bloomberg Administration’s sustainable planning goals by rezoning to protect one of the city’s special lower-density neighborhoods while also providing opportunities for modest growth and permanently affordable housing along wide corridors well served by mass transit.
DCP Press Release

Community efforts for rezoning go back more than the three years DCP has officially been involved. It was a topic of discussion at the first neighborhood association meeting we attended, more than four years ago.


In June 2008, I reported on four major goals for the rezoning, reflecting several of the community concerns that were expressed during Imagine Flatbush 2030. DCP’s press release goes into more detail on how the proposed zoning intends to meet these goals, and added a fifth goal (#2 in this list):

  1. Preserve the existing free-standing (detached) single- and two-family houses.
  2. Preserve Flatbush’s “unique row house neigborhoods.” Some of these rival those in better-known “brownstone Brooklyn” neighborhoods.
  3. Match new zoning to existing buildings as closely as possible without “under zoning”.
  4. Encourage creation of affordable housing through incentives.
  5. Create opportunities for commercial growth.

Proposed Zoning
Flatbush Rezoning Proposal: Proposed Zoning

Existing Zoning
DCP Flatbush Neighborhood Rezoning Existing Zoning

The “ULURP clock” starts with today’s announcement. Community Board review comes next under ULURP. CB14 will schedule a public hearing on the proposal before their formal decision. Review by the Borough President, City Planning Commission, and City Council will complete the process.

Detached Houses

[The proposal will] match new zoning to preserve the established built character of the neighborhood’s lower-density freestanding one- and two-family homes, including 80 blocks of the celebrated early-twentieth century Victorian homes [aka “Victorian Flatbush,” which some call “Ditmas Park”]. Lower density contextual zoning districts (R1-2, R3X and R4A) would replace the existing zoning that permits row houses and apartment buildings with zoning designations that would limit future development to detached housing.

“R” designates residential. The number indicates relative density: R4 is denser than R3. The suffix provides additional restrictions: R3X and R4A only allowed detached homes.

The neighborhoods most affected by this consideration are Caton Park, Beverley Square West and East, Ditmas Park West, and South Midwood. The current zoning for these neighborhoods include R3-1 and R3-2, R4 and R6. Where free-standing – ie: detached – homes still exist, the proposed zoning will be R3X or R4A. And in Prospect Park South, R1-2 zoning is extended west to protect homes that are outside the boundaries of the historic district.

[TinyURL]

Related Content

Flatbush Rezoning Proposal scheduled for certification, 2009-02-28
New Flatbush Rezoning Proposal Gets It Right, 2008-10-07
Flatbush Rezoning Proposal will define the future of Victorian Flatbush, 2008-06-13

Links

PUBLIC REVIEW BEGINS ON CITY PLANNING PROPOSAL TO PROVIDE ZONING PROTECTIONS FOR NEARLY 200 BLOCKS OF FLATBUSH BROOKLYN, Press Release, DCP, 2009-03-02

Brooklyn Community Board 14

Uniform Land Use Review Procedure